Our verdict
The Rad Power Bikes Radster Road and the Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike are too close to call — we rated both 9/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Rad Power Bikes Radster Road
Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike
Side by side
| Attribute | Rad Power Bikes Radster Road | Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 9/10 | 9/10 |
| Best for | One of the best commuter e-bikes tested—powerful motor, Class 3 speeds, and premium quality at an excellent price. | At $1,399, it's the best value step-through we've tested—beating pricier rivals on comfort and design. |
| Standouts |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Rad Power Bikes Radster Road if…
One of the best commuter e-bikes tested—powerful motor, Class 3 speeds, and premium quality at an excellent price.
- 750W motor with 28mph Class 3 speeds
- $2,199 price undercuts competitors by $800+
Choose the Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike if…
At $1,399, it's the best value step-through we've tested—beating pricier rivals on comfort and design.
- Dual suspension and hydraulic disc brakes (rare at this price)
- Integrated battery design keeps aesthetic clean
Why we rate them this way
Rad Power Bikes Radster Road — 9/10
One of the best commuter e-bikes tested—powerful motor, Class 3 speeds, and premium quality at an excellent price.
What we liked: 750W motor with 28mph Class 3 speeds, $2,199 price undercuts competitors by $800+, Premium build quality and refined design, Smart tech with app connectivity for ride customization, Smooth acceleration and quick torque response.
Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike — 9/10
At $1,399, it's the best value step-through we've tested—beating pricier rivals on comfort and design.
What we liked: Dual suspension and hydraulic disc brakes (rare at this price), Integrated battery design keeps aesthetic clean, Hit 32 mph in testing (exceeds 28 mph Class 3 limit), Removable battery enables flexible charging, Comfortable step-through frame with responsive performance.
Common questions
Is the Rad Power Bikes Radster Road or the Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike better?
We rated both 9/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Rad Power Bikes Radster Road: One of the best commuter e-bikes tested—powerful motor, Class 3 speeds, and premium quality at an excellent price. Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike: At $1,399, it's the best value step-through we've tested—beating pricier rivals on comfort and design.
What's the difference between the Rad Power Bikes Radster Road and the Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike?
Short version — Rad Power Bikes Radster Road: One of the best commuter e-bikes tested—powerful motor, Class 3 speeds, and premium quality at an excellent price. Puckipuppy Boxer ST E-Bike: At $1,399, it's the best value step-through we've tested—beating pricier rivals on comfort and design.