Rothy’s Mary Jane vs Our honest Rothy’s Men’s Shoes: Which Is Better?
We tested both Rothy’s Mary Jane and Our honest Rothy’s Men’s Shoes. Here’s the side-by-side on price, ratings, pros, cons, and our honest verdict on which to buy in 2026.
Our verdict: Rothy’s Mary Jane wins (8.5/10).
|
Rothy’s Mary Jane |
Our honest Rothy’s Men’s Shoes |
| Our rating |
8.5/10 |
7.5/10 |
| Price |
— |
— |
| Best for |
— |
— |
| Pros |
- Gorgeous bow design that can be tied multiple ways
- Very comfortable fit with slightly rounded toe
- Made from recycled plastic—sustainable construction
- Excellent value at $155 for the quality
- Removable insoles make cleaning easy
|
- Machine washable
- Made from recycled water bottles (sustainable)
- Comfortable with extra heel padding
- Versatile style for jeans, chinos, or shorts
- Durable, sturdy build
|
| Cons |
- Bow must be tied very tight or straps will rip with wear
- Customer service declined repair/replacement on defective pair
|
- Significantly heavier than competitors (430g vs Allbirds 226g)
- Driving Loafer causes heel rubbing and blisters
- No half sizes available
|
Check Rothy’s Mary Jane price →
Check Our honest Rothy’s Men’s Shoes price →
→ See the full ranking: The Best Shoes We’ve Tested (2026)
