Our verdict
The Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts and the Faherty All Day Shorts are too close to call — we rated both 9/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts
$68
Check priceRead our full review
Faherty All Day Shorts
Side by side
| Attribute | Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts | Faherty All Day Shorts |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 9/10 | 9/10 |
| Best for | Worth the $68 for everyday wear—3+ years in rotation proves it, but skip them for gym workouts. | These live up to the hype—the ultimate do-anything hybrid short that looks like chino but swims like trunks. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
| None we flagged |
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts if…
Worth the $68 for everyday wear—3+ years in rotation proves it, but skip them for gym workouts.
- Zippered pockets keep phone/keys from sliding out
- Incredibly stretchy and breathable
Choose the Faherty All Day Shorts if…
These live up to the hype—the ultimate do-anything hybrid short that looks like chino but swims like trunks.
- Quick-drying (almost suspiciously fast)
- Stretchy and incredibly comfortable
Why we rate them this way
Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts — 9/10
Worth the $68 for everyday wear—3+ years in rotation proves it, but skip them for gym workouts.
What we liked: Zippered pockets keep phone/keys from sliding out, Incredibly stretchy and breathable, Easy to care for and durable, Strong elastic waistband with drawstring, Versatile for casual to light active wear.
Worth knowing: Too thick for athletic or gym use, Lint collects on darker colors, Lean too casual for dressy occasions, Premium $68 price for elevated sweatshorts.
Faherty All Day Shorts — 9/10
These live up to the hype—the ultimate do-anything hybrid short that looks like chino but swims like trunks.
What we liked: Quick-drying (almost suspiciously fast), Stretchy and incredibly comfortable, Hybrid design looks tailored but performs like swim trunks, Water-repellent and moisture-wicking, Made from 75% recycled plastic bottles.
Common questions
Is the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts or the Faherty All Day Shorts better?
We rated both 9/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts: Worth the $68 for everyday wear—3+ years in rotation proves it, but skip them for gym workouts. Faherty All Day Shorts: These live up to the hype—the ultimate do-anything hybrid short that looks like chino but swims like trunks.
How much do the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts and Faherty All Day Shorts cost?
The Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts is listed at $68. We don't have a current price on file for the Faherty All Day Shorts — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts and the Faherty All Day Shorts?
Short version — Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts: Worth the $68 for everyday wear—3+ years in rotation proves it, but skip them for gym workouts. Faherty All Day Shorts: These live up to the hype—the ultimate do-anything hybrid short that looks like chino but swims like trunks.