Our verdict
The Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts and the Olivers Capital Short are too close to call — we rated both 9/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts
$68
Check priceRead our full review
Olivers Capital Short
Side by side
| Attribute | Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts | Olivers Capital Short |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 9/10 | 9/10 |
| Best for | Skip the gym, but killer zippered pockets and three years of constant wear prove they've earned their stellar everyday reputation. | Beats Lululemon Commission Short on stretch and water resistance; 365-day policy makes it worth the extra $9. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts if…
Skip the gym, but killer zippered pockets and three years of constant wear prove they've earned their stellar everyday reputation.
- Zippered side pockets prevent keys and phone from sliding out
- Highly stretchy and breathable material
Choose the Olivers Capital Short if…
Beats Lululemon Commission Short on stretch and water resistance; 365-day policy makes it worth the extra $9.
- Looks like a khaki but moves like an athletic short
- Four-way stretch and incredibly comfortable
Why we rate them this way
Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts — 9/10
Skip the gym, but killer zippered pockets and three years of constant wear prove they've earned their stellar everyday reputation.
What we liked: Zippered side pockets prevent keys and phone from sliding out, Highly stretchy and breathable material, Durable after 3+ years of regular wear, Easy to care for, Generous fit accommodates different body types.
Worth knowing: Not suitable for gym workouts or running, Lint and fuzzies stick to fabric, especially darker colors, Thicker than typical athletic shorts—less lightweight, Look is more casual sweatshorts than dressy chinos.
Olivers Capital Short — 9/10
Beats Lululemon Commission Short on stretch and water resistance; 365-day policy makes it worth the extra $9.
What we liked: Looks like a khaki but moves like an athletic short, Four-way stretch and incredibly comfortable, Durable hardware with built-in button and rubber-lined zipper, Water-repellent, 365-day repair-or-replace policy.
Worth knowing: Can be slightly noisy due to athletic material, Runs large; sizing down recommended, Seam line visible down back of leg.
Common questions
Is the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts or the Olivers Capital Short better?
We rated both 9/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts: Skip the gym, but killer zippered pockets and three years of constant wear prove they've earned their stellar everyday reputation. Olivers Capital Short: Beats Lululemon Commission Short on stretch and water resistance; 365-day policy makes it worth the extra $9.
How much do the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts and Olivers Capital Short cost?
The Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts is listed at $68. We don't have a current price on file for the Olivers Capital Short — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts and the Olivers Capital Short?
Short version — Public Rec All Day Every Day Shorts: Skip the gym, but killer zippered pockets and three years of constant wear prove they've earned their stellar everyday reputation. Olivers Capital Short: Beats Lululemon Commission Short on stretch and water resistance; 365-day policy makes it worth the extra $9.