Our verdict
Between the Bluffworks Polo and the Birddog, we lean toward the Bluffworks Polo — we rated it 7.5/10 versus 4/10. A smart alternative to cotton polos with excellent fit and travel features, though the pique material attracts lint easily.
Our pick
Bluffworks Polo
Birddog
$127
Check priceRead our full reviewSide by side
| Attribute | Bluffworks Polo | Birddog |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 7.5/10 | 4/10 |
| Best for | A smart alternative to cotton polos with excellent fit and travel features, though the pique material attracts lint easily. | At $127, 'fine' is a failure—DUER, Mizzen+Main, and Bluffworks all deliver better value. |
| Standouts |
| |
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Bluffworks Polo if…
A smart alternative to cotton polos with excellent fit and travel features, though the pique material attracts lint easily.
- Looks like real cotton despite being 100% polyester
- Wrinkle-resistant with quick-drying performance
Choose the Birddog if…
At $127, 'fine' is a failure—DUER, Mizzen+Main, and Bluffworks all deliver better value.
Check priceWhy we rate them this way
Bluffworks Polo — 7.5/10
A smart alternative to cotton polos with excellent fit and travel features, though the pique material attracts lint easily.
What we liked: Looks like real cotton despite being 100% polyester, Wrinkle-resistant with quick-drying performance, Perfect fit—not too tight or loose, Great value at $34 (half off retail price), Excellent customer service for color swap.
Worth knowing: Pique material attracts and clings to lint and pet hair, Light colors are see-through (chest hair visible).
Birddog — 4/10
At $127, 'fine' is a failure—DUER, Mizzen+Main, and Bluffworks all deliver better value.
Worth knowing: Arrives wrinkled from factory, poor wrinkle recovery, Performance stretch underwhelming, doesn't snap back, Develops bagginess in knees that won't wash out, Silhouette awkwardly splits athletic and business casual.
Common questions
Is the Bluffworks Polo or the Birddog better?
We rated the Bluffworks Polo 7.5/10 and the Birddog 4/10, so we lean Bluffworks Polo — but it depends on what you want it for (see "which one is right for you" on the page).
How much do the Bluffworks Polo and Birddog cost?
The Birddog is listed at $127. We don't have a current price on file for the Bluffworks Polo — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the Bluffworks Polo and the Birddog?
Short version — Bluffworks Polo: A smart alternative to cotton polos with excellent fit and travel features, though the pique material attracts lint easily. Birddog: At $127, 'fine' is a failure—DUER, Mizzen+Main, and Bluffworks all deliver better value.