Our verdict
The Brooklinen and the Belly Sleeper are too close to call — we rated both 9/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Brooklinen
About $200
Check priceRead our full review
Belly Sleeper
$49.00
Check priceRead our full reviewSide by side
| Attribute | Brooklinen | Belly Sleeper |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 9/10 | 9/10 |
| Price | About $200 | $49.00 |
| Best for | 3 years in, our Luxe Sateen is still hotel-soft, holds color, survived stains, and never pilled—just pull from dryer to skip wrinkles. | The ideal pillow for stomach sleepers—its slim 2.5″ profile finally solves the traditional pillow-too-thick problem. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
| None we flagged |
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Brooklinen if…
3 years in, our Luxe Sateen is still hotel-soft, holds color, survived stains, and never pilled—just pull from dryer to skip wrinkles.
- These Brooklinen sheets are soft. As stated by the brand, they did get softer with washes.
- My sheets feel like satin and shimmer like a velvety night sky.
Choose the Belly Sleeper if…
The ideal pillow for stomach sleepers—its slim 2.5″ profile finally solves the traditional pillow-too-thick problem.
- 2.5" slim profile designed specifically for stomach sleepers
- Cooling gel particles prevent overheating
Why we rate them this way
Brooklinen — 9/10
3 years in, our Luxe Sateen is still hotel-soft, holds color, survived stains, and never pilled—just pull from dryer to skip wrinkles.
What we liked: These Brooklinen sheets are soft. As stated by the brand, they did get softer with washes., My sheets feel like satin and shimmer like a velvety night sky., Long-staple cotton — less likely to pill and maintain a smooth texture..
Worth knowing: Sheets were thinner than they expected., If you don't pull them out of the dryer immediately, they will wrinkle..
Belly Sleeper — 9/10
The ideal pillow for stomach sleepers—its slim 2.5″ profile finally solves the traditional pillow-too-thick problem.
What we liked: 2.5" slim profile designed specifically for stomach sleepers, Cooling gel particles prevent overheating, Bamboo/polyester blend is breathable and moisture-wicking, Natural antimicrobial properties keep fabric fresh, Durable and soft, retains quality after washing.
On price, the Belly Sleeper is the cheaper pick at $49.00, versus About $200 — a difference of about $151.
Common questions
Is the Brooklinen or the Belly Sleeper better?
We rated both 9/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Brooklinen: 3 years in, our Luxe Sateen is still hotel-soft, holds color, survived stains, and never pilled—just pull from dryer to skip wrinkles. Belly Sleeper: The ideal pillow for stomach sleepers—its slim 2.5″ profile finally solves the traditional pillow-too-thick problem.
Which is cheaper, the Brooklinen or the Belly Sleeper?
The Belly Sleeper is the cheaper of the two at $49.00, versus About $200.
What's the difference between the Brooklinen and the Belly Sleeper?
Short version — Brooklinen: 3 years in, our Luxe Sateen is still hotel-soft, holds color, survived stains, and never pilled—just pull from dryer to skip wrinkles. Belly Sleeper: The ideal pillow for stomach sleepers—its slim 2.5″ profile finally solves the traditional pillow-too-thick problem.