Our verdict
The Vessi Shoes and the Amberjack Sneakers are too close to call — we rated both 8.5/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Vessi Shoes
Amberjack Sneakers
$179
Check priceRead our full reviewSide by side
| Attribute | Vessi Shoes | Amberjack Sneakers |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.5/10 | 8.5/10 |
| Best for | Fully waterproof sneakers that actually work and stay breathable, but the polarizing style and puddle-depth limitations make them imperfect. | Dressy sneaker that finally looks grown-up without the stiff feel or maintenance nightmare of actual dress shoes. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Vessi Shoes if…
Fully waterproof sneakers that actually work and stay breathable, but the polarizing style and puddle-depth limitations make them imperfect.
- 100% waterproof—verified through water-pouring tests
- Breathable with no sweaty feet like rain boots
Choose the Amberjack Sneakers if…
Dressy sneaker that finally looks grown-up without the stiff feel or maintenance nightmare of actual dress shoes.
- The leather quality on these is genuinely impressive for the price. Feels like a $300+ sneaker at half the cost.
- Most comfortable leather sneaker I've worn. The cushioning rivals my running shoes but looks 10x better.
Why we rate them this way
Vessi Shoes — 8.5/10
Fully waterproof sneakers that actually work and stay breathable, but the polarizing style and puddle-depth limitations make them imperfect.
What we liked: 100% waterproof—verified through water-pouring tests, Breathable with no sweaty feet like rain boots, Lightweight and comfortable to wear, Machine-washable, Slip-resistant sole.
Worth knowing: Polarizing style won't appeal to everyone, Won't protect from deep puddles—water enters if depth exceeds shoe height, $140 price point.
Amberjack Sneakers — 8.5/10
Dressy sneaker that finally looks grown-up without the stiff feel or maintenance nightmare of actual dress shoes.
What we liked: The leather quality on these is genuinely impressive for the price. Feels like a $300+ sneaker at half the cost., Most comfortable leather sneaker I've worn. The cushioning rivals my running shoes but looks 10x better., Clean enough for the office, comfortable enough for all-day walking. Finally one shoe that does both..
Worth knowing: The white leather shows scuffs easily. You'll need a leather cleaner within the first month., Runs slightly large — had to exchange for a half size down. Their sizing guide wasn't accurate for me..
Common questions
Is the Vessi Shoes or the Amberjack Sneakers better?
We rated both 8.5/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Vessi Shoes: Fully waterproof sneakers that actually work and stay breathable, but the polarizing style and puddle-depth limitations make them imperfect. Amberjack Sneakers: Dressy sneaker that finally looks grown-up without the stiff feel or maintenance nightmare of actual dress shoes.
How much do the Vessi Shoes and Amberjack Sneakers cost?
The Amberjack Sneakers is listed at $179. We don't have a current price on file for the Vessi Shoes — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the Vessi Shoes and the Amberjack Sneakers?
Short version — Vessi Shoes: Fully waterproof sneakers that actually work and stay breathable, but the polarizing style and puddle-depth limitations make them imperfect. Amberjack Sneakers: Dressy sneaker that finally looks grown-up without the stiff feel or maintenance nightmare of actual dress shoes.