Our verdict
The &Collar Dress Shirts and the Buck Mason are too close to call — we rated both 8/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
&Collar Dress Shirts
Buck Mason
$45
Check priceRead our full reviewSide by side
| Attribute | &Collar Dress Shirts | Buck Mason |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8/10 | 8/10 |
| Best for | A great alternative to Mizzen+Main at a fraction of the price, nearly as good with unique patterns. | After 7+ years of wear-testing, Buck Mason is our trusted go-to for durable, timeless men's basics. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the &Collar Dress Shirts if…
A great alternative to Mizzen+Main at a fraction of the price, nearly as good with unique patterns.
- andCollar shirts are incredibly soft and the stretch is perfect for guys who lift. Best dress shirt for muscular builds.
- Great alternative to Mizzen+Main at a lower price point. The performance fabric is comparable.
Choose the Buck Mason if…
After 7+ years of wear-testing, Buck Mason is our trusted go-to for durable, timeless men's basics.
- Tri-Blend Tees exceptional—$45, perfect weight, 10+ in rotation with zero issues
- American-made quality and construction
Why we rate them this way
&Collar Dress Shirts — 8/10
A great alternative to Mizzen+Main at a fraction of the price, nearly as good with unique patterns.
What we liked: andCollar shirts are incredibly soft and the stretch is perfect for guys who lift. Best dress shirt for muscular builds., Great alternative to Mizzen+Main at a lower price point. The performance fabric is comparable., Love the fit and feel. I've bought 5 of these now and they're all I wear to work., Perfect for business casual. The stretch makes them way more comfortable than traditional dress shirts..
Worth knowing: The collar tends to curl after a few washes. Minor issue but annoying for a dress shirt., Shipping was slow — took almost 2 weeks to arrive. Product was good though..
Buck Mason — 8/10
After 7+ years of wear-testing, Buck Mason is our trusted go-to for durable, timeless men's basics.
What we liked: Tri-Blend Tees exceptional—$45, perfect weight, 10+ in rotation with zero issues, American-made quality and construction, Exceptional durability proven over 7+ years, Mix-and-match versatility across the range, Timeless, classic aesthetic that transcends trends.
Worth knowing: Lacks high-performance features compared to competitors like Mizzen+Main and Duer, Limited physical store locations (only California and New York), Less stretch and comfort in jeans versus newer brands, Button-up shirts require ironing and wrinkle easily.
Common questions
Is the &Collar Dress Shirts or the Buck Mason better?
We rated both 8/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. &Collar Dress Shirts: A great alternative to Mizzen+Main at a fraction of the price, nearly as good with unique patterns. Buck Mason: After 7+ years of wear-testing, Buck Mason is our trusted go-to for durable, timeless men's basics.
How much do the &Collar Dress Shirts and Buck Mason cost?
The Buck Mason is listed at $45. We don't have a current price on file for the &Collar Dress Shirts — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the &Collar Dress Shirts and the Buck Mason?
Short version — &Collar Dress Shirts: A great alternative to Mizzen+Main at a fraction of the price, nearly as good with unique patterns. Buck Mason: After 7+ years of wear-testing, Buck Mason is our trusted go-to for durable, timeless men's basics.