Our verdict
The Buck Mason and the Ultimate Robert Barakett are too close to call — we rated both 8/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Buck Mason
$45
Check priceRead our full review
Ultimate Robert Barakett
Side by side
| Attribute | Buck Mason | Ultimate Robert Barakett |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8/10 | 8/10 |
| Best for | After 7+ years of testing, Buck Mason is our go-to brand for timeless, durable men's basics—the Tri-Blend Tees especially are worth buying in bulk. | Softest shirts we've tested—premium price is steep but justified by quality, though you might keep them too nice to wear. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Buck Mason if…
After 7+ years of testing, Buck Mason is our go-to brand for timeless, durable men's basics—the Tri-Blend Tees especially are worth buying in bulk.
- Tri-Blend Tees: perfect weight, comfort, durability with zero quality issues
- American-made construction
Choose the Ultimate Robert Barakett if…
Softest shirts we've tested—premium price is steep but justified by quality, though you might keep them too nice to wear.
- Softest fabric we've tried—feels like a second skin
- Perfect fit: flattering without being clingy
Why we rate them this way
Buck Mason — 8/10
After 7+ years of testing, Buck Mason is our go-to brand for timeless, durable men's basics—the Tri-Blend Tees especially are worth buying in bulk.
What we liked: Tri-Blend Tees: perfect weight, comfort, durability with zero quality issues, American-made construction, Timeless, versatile basics that mix-and-match seamlessly, Durable and easy-care fabrics, Sustainable manufacturing practices.
Worth knowing: Not high-performance like Mizzen+Main or Duer, Limited physical store locations (CA and NY only), Button-up shirts wrinkle easily and require ironing, Jeans lack stretch compared to newer brands.
Ultimate Robert Barakett — 8/10
Softest shirts we've tested—premium price is steep but justified by quality, though you might keep them too nice to wear.
What we liked: Softest fabric we've tried—feels like a second skin, Perfect fit: flattering without being clingy, Vibrant colors don't fade after washing, Sustainable, eco-friendly materials (organic cotton), Huge color selection: 38 options for the signature tee.
Worth knowing: Premium price ($69.50) vs competitors like Buck Mason ($45), Expensive enough that you hesitate to actually wear them, Light colors show chest hair visibility.
Common questions
Is the Buck Mason or the Ultimate Robert Barakett better?
We rated both 8/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Buck Mason: After 7+ years of testing, Buck Mason is our go-to brand for timeless, durable men's basics—the Tri-Blend Tees especially are worth buying in bulk. Ultimate Robert Barakett: Softest shirts we've tested—premium price is steep but justified by quality, though you might keep them too nice to wear.
How much do the Buck Mason and Ultimate Robert Barakett cost?
The Buck Mason is listed at $45. We don't have a current price on file for the Ultimate Robert Barakett — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the Buck Mason and the Ultimate Robert Barakett?
Short version — Buck Mason: After 7+ years of testing, Buck Mason is our go-to brand for timeless, durable men's basics—the Tri-Blend Tees especially are worth buying in bulk. Ultimate Robert Barakett: Softest shirts we've tested—premium price is steep but justified by quality, though you might keep them too nice to wear.