Compare Products

GREATS Shoe vs Rothy’s: Which Is Better?

We tested both GREATS Shoe and Rothy’s. Here’s the side-by-side on price, ratings, pros, cons, and our honest verdict on which to buy in 2026.

GREATS Shoe Rothy’s
Our rating 8.5/10 8.5/10
Price $119
Best for
Pros
  • Machine washable for easy maintenance
  • 100% vegan with knit upper made from recycled plastic bottles
  • Unique, beautiful design that works dressed up or down
  • High-grade rubber outsole for grip and durability
  • True to size fit with solid structure
  • Made from recycled water bottles (eco-friendly)
  • Machine-washable and easy to clean
  • Versatile across casual and dressy settings
  • Lightweight and comfortable insoles
  • Durable with reinforced toe shells
Cons
  • Slightly heavier than comparable sneakers like SUAVS
  • Made in China rather than Italy
  • Minimal branding on tongue is hard to see on white colorway
  • Expensive / splurge price point
  • Runs snug — need to size up half a size

Check GREATS Shoe price →

Check Rothy’s price →