Rothy’s Review: An honest review of the internet’s hottest shoe brand

Mrs. We Tried It

Rothy’s Shoe Review: Hey there, fabulous people! Ever scrolled through your Instagram feed and stumbled upon a pair of shoes that made you stop, stare, and wonder, “Are these as good as they look?” Well, we’ve got you covered! We’re diving feet-first into the world of Rothy’s—the Internet’s hottest shoe brand that’s got everyone from your trendy neighbor to Meghan Markle raving.

Why are these kicks the talk of the town, you ask? Picture this: shoes made from recycled water bottles that are not just eco-friendly but also machine-washable. Yep, you heard that right. Spill coffee on ’em? No problemo. Just toss them in the wash, and they come out looking brand-spanking new.

One of our top women's shoe brands
Rothys Shoes

Rothy's Shoe Review: Amazingly comfortable shoes - even if they are made out of plastic. We love the amazing comfort, classic styles and machine washable practicality!

Buy Now
We might earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Quick Hits from Our Rothy’s Review: The Good and the Not-So-Good

In the spirit of keeping it real, here’s a condensed version of our Rothy’s experience:

Eco-Friendly Fashion: Rothy’s are a win for your wardrobe and the planet, crafted from recycled water bottles.
Comfort Meets Chic: Perfect for any setting, these shoes blend comfort with style seamlessly.
Durability That Delivers: Long-lasting and machine washable, they’re an eco-conscious investment.
Sizing Advice: Heads up, they tend to run snug. Sizing up is a smart move for the best fit.
Feel-Good Factor: Each step in Rothy’s feels like a positive stride for the environment.
Price Point: The one downside? They’re a bit of a splurge. But for many, the quality and eco-friendliness justify the cost.

Want to save on Rothy’s?

If you want to save on Rothy’s be sure to use our exclusive Rothy’s Promo Code.

What’s the big deal with Rothy’s?

Rothy’s shoes are interesting for a variety of reasons.

The biggest is: they are made from recycled water bottles.

How does that actually work? Really well actually. The shoes are made out of strong fiber-like material that is the recycled water bottles. But Rothy’s didn’t just want to create a shoe from water bottles. Here’s what they have to say about their mission:

At Rothy’s, our mission is to create a new kind of shoe for women: one that is versatile, chic and durable. And we want to do it right, with as little waste and impact to the environment as possible.

Also, they are machine washable. Being machine washable + sustainable = even more sustainable. They also claim to be lightweight, breathable and super comfortable.

That all sounds good, but what about the shoes? Do Rothy’s Shoes live up to the hype?

A day in the life of Rothys

In the midst of all the facts and features, let me take you through my own Rothy’s journey. It’s one thing to read about the specs, but another to hear how they fare in the wild, right?

The First Step: Skepticism Meets Surprise

When I first slipped my feet into these recycled-bottle shoes, I’ll admit, I was a skeptic. Could something spun from plastic really hug my feet in comfort? Spoiler alert: It was like stepping into a surprise party for my feet.

The Love Affair with Versatility

What really made me fall head over heels for Rothy’s is their chameleon-like versatility. They’ve been my sidekick for casual coffee dates and even those dress-to-impress events. It’s like having a secret weapon in my shoe arsenal that works with just about any outfit.

The Price Hurdle: An Investment in Comfort

I won’t beat around the bush – the price made me think twice. It felt like a leap, but considering how they’ve held up and the sheer frequency of wear, they’ve earned their keep in my wardrobe.

A Tip from Me to You

If you’re on the fence about sizing, my advice is to go half a size up. And when it comes to cleaning, don’t hesitate to pop them in the wash. They come out looking and feeling fresh, ready for their next adventure.

My Verdict: More Than Just Shoes

So, would I recommend Rothy’s? In a heartbeat. They’re not just a pair of shoes; they’ve become a part of my lifestyle. Comfortable, stylish, and eco-friendly – Rothy’s are a triple threat that I’ve gladly welcomed into my life.

Rothy’s Shoe Review: What Did We Try??

We’ve tried a lot of Rothys products.

It’s hard to believe we did our first Rothy’s Review over 4 years ago. This is our full Rothys review, were we will tell you about everything Rothys and ultimately, if Rothy’s worth the premium price to buy Rothy’s.

Since then, our world (and the world around us, has changed dramatically).

We’ve tried all of these amazing Rothys products and even more…

We tried several types of Rothy’s Shoes: from the signature Point to their new Sneaker to their bags (read our Rothy’s Bag Review) to their mens shoes (read our Rothy’s Mens Review) to even the Men’s Rothys Wallet (read our Rothy’s Wallet Review).

We’ve even dived deeper into some of other styles like our Mary Jane Review and our Rothys Merino Review.

Rothys Shoes – The Quick Reviews

Of course, since we’ve tried so many styles, we want to give you quick reviews of each Rothys Style. But let’s start with the shoe that started it all: the Rothys Point – AKA the Rothy’s Flats.

Rothys Point Review

The shoe that started it all
The Points - Rothys Shoes

You can't go wrong with The Point - the Rothys style that started it all. As long as you are OK with a little "toe cleavage" this is an incredible show.

Buy Now
We might earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The first shoe Mrs. We Tried it wanted to review is the Point. It looks like a signature pointed flat.

Rothy's Promo Code
Made with recycled plastic water bottles. A great travel shoe and great shoe overall.

This shoe is one of the shoes that made Rothy’s really popular. Mr. We Tried It was skeptical that the leopard print would look cheesy and forced. However, in person, these shoes look great! The signature blue outline on the heel gives it a nice, classy touch of branding without being too over-the-top.

The shoes are amazingly light – on par with Allbirds (read our Allbirds Review). They are also super comfortable.

In the next photo, you can see that the shoe is made up of a tight weave (that’s the plastic bottles we mentioned earlier). You can tell that it is a weave of material but it looks very nice.

Rothy’s Point: Fit + Comfort

Mrs. We Tried It typically wears a size 7.5 in almost every brand. She found that the point ran a little small and she needed to size up half a size to an 8 in the Rothy’s Point.

The 7.5 was simply too snug to be comfortable.

As already mentioned, the Rothy’s Point is extremely lightweight.

That makes it extremely comfortable and easy to wear. The plastic bottle weave pattern also makes the shoes slightly breathable. So – they would be very cold in cooler weather, but awesome if you have feet that run a little hot.

Rothy’s Point Fit

We recommend you size up a half size in the Rothy’s Point styles.

Rothy’s Point: The style of the pointed toe

Our first pair of Rothy’s Flats were not the rounded toe flats, but the pointed toe flats.

Overall, we really liked the style of the Rothy’s Point Shoe. It’s a great, classy twist on the classic flat. The leopard print is a lot of fun and looks great in person.

The Rothy’s Point can we worn easily with jean or leggings.

The Rothy’s Point also has a very deep “V” in the front.

It was a little too deep for Mrs. We Tried It, but that’s a personal preference. If you don’t prefer to have “toe cleavage” you might want to look at another one of the Rothy’s Styles.

Rothy’s Shoes: The Rothy’s Flats Review

Of course, we can’t talk about Rothys without talking about the Rothy’s Flats. For most folks, this is their first pair of Rothy’s, and for good reason!

The classic round toe and flat design is the one pair that people remember this shoe brand for.

Rothy’s Review: The Women’s Sneaker

Since Mrs. We Tried It is such a big fan of the Allbirds Wool Lounger, we also wanted to try the brand new Rothy’s Sneaker. The shoe has a thicker, cushier (is that a real word?!) sole for added comfort and stability.

rothys promo code

It is made of the same, comfortable recycled water bottles on the upper and also features the Rothy’s Signature blue around the heel. There is also a nice blue touch on the back of the shoe. Some might not like the amount of color on the back, but we really liked it.

One of our favorite Rothy’s Shoe Styles – durable shoes that are slip-on sneakers. Made from the same recycled plastic bottles as the other shoes.

The shoes are not as light as the Rothy’s Point but the Rothy’s Sneakers are still very light.

Rothy’s Sneaker: Fit + Comfort Review

As mentioned, Mrs. We Tried It typically wears a size 7.5 in almost every brand. The sneakers ran more true to size and wears a 7.5 in the Rothy’s sneakers, too.

These sneakers are incredibly comfortable. Mrs. We Tried It called it the second most-comfortable shoes she owns (more on that in just a second).

But the combination of a better looking shoe and comfort made the Rothy’s Sneaker a must-have for a Mom of (newly) 2 kiddos.

We recommend you order the size your normally wear for Rothy’s Sneakers.

Want a different shoe style? Check out our Kizik Review and Wolf + Shepherd Review.

Rothy’s Sneaker: Style Review

The Rothy’s Sneakers simply look like a classy variation of the classic sneaker. That’s great. They’ve got a little touch of color, but it’s not over the top.

The Rothy’s Sneakers go well with Jeans or Tights.

Rothys Mens Shoes: Quick Review

Finally… Rothy’s Shoes are available for men.

As we mentioned in our Rothys Men Review, we really like the RS01 Sneaker. It’s stylish, super comfortable, breathable AND machine washable.

Men’s Rothys Sneakers Video Review

A great pick
Rothys Men's Shoes

Great design, machine washable, breathable and incredibly comfortable - we love Rothys take on men's shoes. From the RS01 Sneaker to the driving loafer, now men can experience Rothys comfort.

Buy Now
We might earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

That’s even more reason why we love the bright white color.

We don’t have to stress about it getting too dirty (and we aren’t scared to wear them like we are our Oliver Cabell Low 1 Shoes – they are almost too pretty to wear!).

Rothys Mens Driver Quick Review

An awesome loafer
Rothys Men's Driving Loafer

An awesome twist on the driving loafer. These are machine-washable, like the rest of Rothys.

Buy Now
We might earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

These shoes are another incredible comfortable take on a classic style for anyone wanting to buy Rothy’s. Our Rothy’s Review of these? AWESOME!

Break these in gently. In real life, Mr. We Tried It got a bit of a blister in the back after walking miles in the shoes the very first time. Just break-in this shoe in the men’s line.

They are perfect for hot days, too!

It’s also a great travel shoe (after you break them in a bit). Not only are they super breathable – they are also machine washable, like the others.

Just machine wash with cold water, delicate cycle, and let them hand dry. The Cold water and Delicate cycle is key!

Rothys Merino Quick Review

Made from the same recycled materials + merino wool – the pointed flats with the perfect fit!

If you’re a fan of Rothy’s shoes, you’ll love their new Merino Collection!

These shoes are made with warmer materials, giving you a more polished look.

The variety of colors and styles available gives you lots of new options to choose from.

Note: these shoes are currently out of stock on Rothys website.

The sizing can be a little tricky, so be sure to order the right size (order your true size, not a half size larger, like other Rothys).

The price can be a bit steep, but the shoes are sustainably sourced and can be washed, which extends their life.

These shoes are not only warmer but also more polished— perfect for a professional atmosphere. So if you’re looking for a comfortable and stylish shoe, check out Rothy’s Merino Collection!

Rothys Bag Review

Get free shipping on your next order, too from this awesome brand!

Rothys took their innovative technology and created a new line of bags that are machine-washable, made from recycled plastic water bottles, and look amazing.

The best part? These bags come in so many different styles that there is sure to be one (or more) perfect for you.

Our Favorite Rothys Bag
Rothys Tote Bags

Our go-to bag for the pool and summer activities. The fact this tote is machine washable is a game-changer. You can now look stylish while lugging around kids' junk!

Buy Now
We might earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

From work totes to crossbody bags, Rothy’s has got you covered. This summer, I used a Rothys Lightweight Tote to and from the pool. Why? Because it’s machine washable! I had so many of the totes designed for outdoor activities. This tote looks like a real tote but no one has to know it’s also machine washable.

Rothys Bags Video Review

So, what are you waiting for? Go check out the newest Rothy’s Bags today!

Rothys Boot Review

Rothys Mary Jane Quick Review – why you might want to skip this pair

The Rothys Mary Jane shoes are a stylish and comfortable option for those looking for a new pair of shoes.

They have a similar silhouette to the Rothys The Point, but feature a more rounded toe.

Additionally, they have vegan leather soles which elevate the shoe and make it look more polished.

Rothys Flats with a Twist

The bow on the top of the shoe can be tied in a number of different ways, and Rothys is always coming out with new colors and styles. At $155, these shoes are a great value.

The small design flaw

Rothy’s has been a product that has gotten tons of positive posts on our site. I first purchased these Mary Jane shoes and was so in love with them!

Unfortunately, in my opinion, they have a design flaw: you have to tie them pretty tight to keep the bow secured and that made the fabric on the straps rip. After only a couple of wears, the straps on my Wildcat pair ripped.

I will look into getting them repaired because I still want to wear them, but before I did that I reached out to Rothy’s.

Rothy’s said that they would not repair, replace or exchange them but they did offer me $30 off a replacement pair.

That to me is a bummer because they cost $155 and I feel like they should do more about this issue since it is a design flaw with their shoe.

I also think they would have done more in the past (and have for me on other occasions), but maybe they are getting too big or just not as interested in making their customers happy.

Rothys Merino Boots Review

A great boot!
Rothy's - The Boot

Rothy's take on the classic boot. It's the one Rothy's pair we wear with socks, but it's still a great shoe!

Buy Now
We might earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Are you looking for a versatile boot to take you through the colder months? Rothys has you covered with their Chelsea Boot. Made with recycled thread, these boots are comfortable and can be easily washed. With a variety of colors to choose from, you’re sure to find the perfect pair for you.

The iconic chelsea boot and their unique take. Perfect for cobblestone streets and stomping around San Francisco!

Rothys Chelsea Boots run true to size and are a great addition to your cold weather wardrobe.

Probably not the first pair of Rothy’s we’d recommend in our Rothy’s Shoes Review, but a unique sustainable shoe design.

In fact, they are the only Rothys shoe we ever wear socks with. That’s because they are made with Merino wool, which is not only eco-friendly but also provides great insulation.

If you’re looking for a stylish and sustainable boot to keep you warm this winter, Rothys Chelsea Boots are a great option. Be sure to use our exclusive promo code to save on your purchase.

Rothys Driving Loafer – Quick Review

We have the Rothys Driving Loafer for men and women. If you’re looking for a stylish and comfortable driving shoe (or even just a comfortable shoe), look no further than the driving loafer from Rothy’s.

Made of recycled materials, these shoes are environmentally friendly and perfect for everyday wear. However, a quick warning: the back of the shoe can rub your heel the wrong way and cause some blisters. So, just a quick tip: even if you size up a half size (Rothy’s doesn’t have half sizes), you could get some rubbing.

The subtle purple in highlights our personal style from this amazing shoe company – you won’t find these fun colors in other shoe brands.

What’s interesting is we both had the same issue (in boths mens and womens) I recommend that you wear them without a bandaid in short bursts, but make sure you

have a bandaid on you if you need it. They are the same style in men and women (made from the same recycled materials) but they can cause some blisters. I didn’t have the same problem with the RS01 Sneaker. just the Driving Loafer.

Are Rothy’s Really Machine Washable?

One area we haven’t talked about is how Rothy’s are washable! It’s one of the great features that is very similar to Allbirds (see: How To Wash Allbirds).

Simply take out the laces, insoles and machine wash on delicate. After they are done, simply air dry.

Rothy’s Shoe Care Kit

Rothy’s does sell a “Care Kit” for washing the shoes. If washing the shoes with traditional detergent (we recommend Woolite Dark for most items like Allbirds and Mizzen + Main) doesn’t work, we’ll try the Rothy’s Care Kit.

The Rothy’s Return Policy is pretty simple: visit a webpage and start the process. It’s pretty straightforward and easy to use.

The only downside is that the shoes have to be unworn (don’t worry, you can obviously try them on, just don’t take them out of your home!). We had to return a couple pairs (due to the sizing we talked about above) – so don’t be afraid to order a couple more pairs and return the ones that don’t fit or you don’t like.

Do you wear socks with Rothys?

Lock mom! No socks!

We, personally, don’t wear socks with Rothy’s shoes – especially the Rothy’s flats or Rothys Shoes for guys.

How durable are Rothy shoes?

Incredibly durable. We’ve gad pairs of Rothy’s flats (both rounded toe and the pointed toe flats) for over 5 years. That’s a long time in the world of shoes! Not only are these the most comfortable flats I own, they are also one of the most durable in our shoe collection.

The only exception to this is

Allbirds vs. Rothy’s Shoes

What is better? Rothy’s or Allbirds? It all depends on what you are looking for.

As mentioned, the Rothy’s Sneaker is the second most comfortable shoe that Mrs. We Tried It owns. The most comfortable? The Allbirds Wool Lounger. So, that begs the question…

It’s natural to want to compare Allbirds to Rothy’s. They are both direct-to-consumer new products. They both come from sustainable materials (Allbirds is made of sustainable Wool). They both are washable. They are both about the same price. They both have a cult-like following.

However, there’s one big area where the Rothy’s and Allbirds are very different: the Style.

Mrs. We Tried It loves her Allbirds Wool Loungers. But good friends have asked her if she’s wearing her slippers around town – which is kinda true. The Allbirds Wool Loungers are incredibly comfortable and lightweight.

However, Rothy’s actually look like Sneakers, not slippers. Granted there are different styles of Allbirds, but Mrs. We Tried It wouldn’t wear anything but the loungers.

The Rothy’s sneakers are simply a better style with many of the same features and benefits as Allbirds.

Winner: Rothy’s for anything that takes you outside the home, at least for Women. Even for Men, we prefer the Rothy’s RS01 Sneaker over Allbirds brands in terms of looks. However, the Allbirds are lighter weight and slightly more comfortable!

Rothy’s Shoes Review: The Final Verdict

We simply love so many thing about Rothy’s: the comfort, the breathability, how they can be machine washable, worn without socks and simply look great.

You’ll be hard pressed to find a shoe (even beyond the classic Rothy’s Flats that started it all) that comes close to the features AND looks of Rothys. If you haven’t tried one of these Rothy’s Styles, you’re missing out and should consider it for your next pair of new shoes.

With normal wear, expect shoes from Rothy’s (even the different styles) to last for years to come.

Even for the most budget conscious person, these shoes are a great value – as they will last longer than other flats or other shoes from other brands.

One of our top women's shoe brands
Rothys Shoes

Rothy's Shoe Review: Amazingly comfortable shoes - even if they are made out of plastic. We love the amazing comfort, classic styles and machine washable practicality!

Buy Now
We might earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Is Rothys a Chinese company?

No, Rothys is not a Chinese company. However, they do own a sustainable factory in Dongguan, China that they source all of their shoes from. A Their team works closely with both the factory and suppliers to ensure that everything meets their high standards for quality and sustainability. In addition to being incredibly well-made, their shoes are also super stylish and comfortable – perfect for everyday wear!

Are Rothys good for your feet?

Rothys are definitely good for your feet! The minimalism design means that there’s less material between your foot and the ground, so it’s more natural and comfortable. And because they’re so lightweight, you won’t get fatigued as quickly.

Does Meghan Markle wear Rothys shoes?

Yes! Meghan is a big fan of Rothy’s shoes and has been seen wearing them on multiple occasions.

Rothy’s is a San Francisco-based company that makes stylish, comfortable flats out of recycled water bottles. The shoes are made to order and can be customized in a variety of different colors and styles. Meghan has been spotted wearing the Pointed Toe Flat, the Round Toe Flat, and the Loafer style.

Are Rothys waterproof?

No, Rothys are not waterproof.

18 thoughts on “Rothy’s Review: An honest review of the internet’s hottest shoe brand”

Leave a Reply