Our verdict
The Hey Dude Shoes and Rothy’s Mary Jane are close. We gave the Hey Dude Shoes a slight edge at 5.5/10 over the Rothy’s Mary Jane at 5/10 — close enough that fit matters more than the score. Lightweight and comfortable, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality issues we encountered make them a pass.
Our pick
Hey Dude Shoes
Rothy’s Mary Jane
Side by side
| Attribute | Hey Dude Shoes | Rothy’s Mary Jane |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 5.5/10 | 5/10 |
| Best for | Lightweight and comfortable, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality issues we encountered make them a pass. | Beautiful design undermined by fragile bow straps and disappointing customer service. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Hey Dude Shoes if…
Lightweight and comfortable, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality issues we encountered make them a pass.
- Extremely lightweight (177g, minimal packing)
- Comfortable memory foam + EVA cushioning
Choose the Rothy’s Mary Jane if…
Beautiful design undermined by fragile bow straps and disappointing customer service.
- Cute bow design and elegant style
- Very comfortable fit with rounded toe
Why we rate them this way
Hey Dude Shoes — 5.5/10
Lightweight and comfortable, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality issues we encountered make them a pass.
What we liked: Extremely lightweight (177g, minimal packing), Comfortable memory foam + EVA cushioning, Machine washable, Removable insoles for customization, Built-in arch support.
Worth knowing: Aggressively casual, not stylish, Cushioning degrades with heavy use, Product defects and quality issues, Poor customer service.
Rothy’s Mary Jane — 5/10
Beautiful design undermined by fragile bow straps and disappointing customer service.
What we liked: Cute bow design and elegant style, Very comfortable fit with rounded toe, Made from recycled plastic (sustainable), Good price for quality shoes ($155), Machine washable with removable insoles.
Worth knowing: Bow straps ripped after only a couple of wears, Design flaw: requires extremely tight tying to keep bow secure, Poor customer service: refused repair or replacement, only offered $30 discount.
Common questions
Is the Hey Dude Shoes or the Rothy’s Mary Jane better?
We rated the Hey Dude Shoes 5.5/10 and the Rothy’s Mary Jane 5/10, so we lean Hey Dude Shoes — but it depends on what you want it for (see "which one is right for you" on the page).
What's the difference between the Hey Dude Shoes and the Rothy’s Mary Jane?
Short version — Hey Dude Shoes: Lightweight and comfortable, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality issues we encountered make them a pass. Rothy’s Mary Jane: Beautiful design undermined by fragile bow straps and disappointing customer service.