Our verdict
Between the Mugsy Jeans and the Quince, we lean toward the Mugsy Jeans — we rated it 10/10 versus 9/10. The most comfortable jeans we've tested—at ~$110, they feel like sweatpants but look like real jeans, earning a 10/10 on comfort.
Our pick
Mugsy Jeans
$112
Check priceRead our full review
Quince
Side by side
| Attribute | Mugsy Jeans | Quince |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 10/10 | 9/10 |
| Best for | The most comfortable jeans we've tested—at ~$110, they feel like sweatpants but look like real jeans, earning a 10/10 on comfort. | We tested 47+ Quince items and the cashmere ($59) and polos ($34) are the real wins: soft, affordable, and hard to fault. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Mugsy Jeans if…
The most comfortable jeans we've tested—at ~$110, they feel like sweatpants but look like real jeans, earning a 10/10 on comfort.
- Feels like sweatpants but looks like real jeans
- Proprietary stretchy fabric moves with you instead of constricting
Choose the Quince if…
We tested 47+ Quince items and the cashmere ($59) and polos ($34) are the real wins: soft, affordable, and hard to fault.
- Ultra-soft cashmere, not scratchy at all
- Lightweight performance polos genuinely hard to fault
Why we rate them this way
Mugsy Jeans — 10/10
The most comfortable jeans we've tested—at ~$110, they feel like sweatpants but look like real jeans, earning a 10/10 on comfort.
What we liked: Feels like sweatpants but looks like real jeans, Proprietary stretchy fabric moves with you instead of constricting, Stretchy waist requires no wiggling to put on, Holds shape and waistband doesn't sag after multiple wears, Free returns make it easy to dial in the perfect fit.
Worth knowing: Runs a touch baggy; requires sizing down.
Quince — 9/10
We tested 47+ Quince items and the cashmere ($59) and polos ($34) are the real wins: soft, affordable, and hard to fault.
What we liked: Ultra-soft cashmere, not scratchy at all, Lightweight performance polos genuinely hard to fault, Incredibly affordable for the quality, Ethically sourced under Good Cashmere Standard, True-to-size fit on most pieces.
Worth knowing: Dress shirts wrinkle badly, lose to Mizzen + Main, Cashmere sweatpants run large.
Common questions
Is the Mugsy Jeans or the Quince better?
We rated the Mugsy Jeans 10/10 and the Quince 9/10, so we lean Mugsy Jeans — but it depends on what you want it for (see "which one is right for you" on the page).
How much do the Mugsy Jeans and Quince cost?
The Mugsy Jeans is listed at $112. We don't have a current price on file for the Quince — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the Mugsy Jeans and the Quince?
Short version — Mugsy Jeans: The most comfortable jeans we've tested—at ~$110, they feel like sweatpants but look like real jeans, earning a 10/10 on comfort. Quince: We tested 47+ Quince items and the cashmere ($59) and polos ($34) are the real wins: soft, affordable, and hard to fault.