Our verdict
Between the Myles Everyday Short and the Olivers All Over Short, we lean toward the Myles Everyday Short — we rated it 8.5/10 versus 6.5/10. A top-pick go-to short that works for everything—from workouts and errands to casual wear and even swimming.
Our pick
Myles Everyday Short
$68
Check priceRead our full review
Olivers All Over Short
$75
Read our full reviewSide by side
| Attribute | Myles Everyday Short | Olivers All Over Short |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.5/10 | 6.5/10 |
| Price | $68 | $75 |
| Best for | A top-pick go-to short that works for everything—from workouts and errands to casual wear and even swimming. | Excellent performer and durable, but the added front-leg logo killed what made it special—Myles is the better buy now. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Myles Everyday Short if…
A top-pick go-to short that works for everything—from workouts and errands to casual wear and even swimming.
- Incredibly comfortable with lasting elastic waistband
- Much quieter fabric (new version improvement)
Choose the Olivers All Over Short if…
Excellent performer and durable, but the added front-leg logo killed what made it special—Myles is the better buy now.
- Quick-drying, excellent moisture-wicking fabric
- Lightweight with minimal noise
Why we rate them this way
Myles Everyday Short — 8.5/10
A top-pick go-to short that works for everything—from workouts and errands to casual wear and even swimming.
What we liked: Incredibly comfortable with lasting elastic waistband, Much quieter fabric (new version improvement), Versatile for workouts, errands, casual, and swimming, Water-repellent and quick-dry performance, Easy to style for different occasions.
Worth knowing: Occasional pilling, More athletic-looking than traditional shorts, Less breathable than mesh alternatives, Not ideal for formal or dressy occasions.
Olivers All Over Short — 6.5/10
Excellent performer and durable, but the added front-leg logo killed what made it special—Myles is the better buy now.
What we liked: Quick-drying, excellent moisture-wicking fabric, Lightweight with minimal noise, True-to-size fit, multiple inseam options, Versatile for athletic and casual wear, Durable (3+ years of regular use).
Worth knowing: Raised logo added to front leg (deal-breaker), Logo very noticeable on lighter colors, No back pocket (unlike Myles alternative), Can't dress up as well as alternatives.
On price, the Myles Everyday Short is the cheaper pick at $68, versus $75 — a difference of about $7.
Common questions
Is the Myles Everyday Short or the Olivers All Over Short better?
We rated the Myles Everyday Short 8.5/10 and the Olivers All Over Short 6.5/10, so we lean Myles Everyday Short — but it depends on what you want it for (see "which one is right for you" on the page).
Which is cheaper, the Myles Everyday Short or the Olivers All Over Short?
The Myles Everyday Short is the cheaper of the two at $68, versus $75.
What's the difference between the Myles Everyday Short and the Olivers All Over Short?
Short version — Myles Everyday Short: A top-pick go-to short that works for everything—from workouts and errands to casual wear and even swimming. Olivers All Over Short: Excellent performer and durable, but the added front-leg logo killed what made it special—Myles is the better buy now.