Our verdict
The Rothy’s Mary Jane and the GREATS Shoe are too close to call — we rated both 8/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Rothy’s Mary Jane
GREATS Shoe
$119
Check priceRead our full reviewSide by side
| Attribute | Rothy’s Mary Jane | GREATS Shoe |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8/10 | 8/10 |
| Best for | My favorite Rothy's yet—elegant, comfy, and eco-conscious, but the tight bow can strain straps. | Solid choice. Worth buying if it solves your problem. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Rothy’s Mary Jane if…
My favorite Rothy's yet—elegant, comfy, and eco-conscious, but the tight bow can strain straps.
- Elegant bow design that's cute and stylish
- Very comfortable fit with rounded toe
Choose the GREATS Shoe if…
Solid choice. Worth buying if it solves your problem.
- Machine-washable—easy maintenance without specialized products
- Beautiful, distinctive design with subtle branding
Why we rate them this way
Rothy’s Mary Jane — 8/10
My favorite Rothy's yet—elegant, comfy, and eco-conscious, but the tight bow can strain straps.
What we liked: Elegant bow design that's cute and stylish, Very comfortable fit with rounded toe, Made from recycled plastic (sustainable), Vegan leather soles add sophistication, Good value at $155 for the quality.
Worth knowing: Bow must be tied extremely tight to stay secured, Straps can rip from tight bow—reviewer's pair failed after a couple wears, Poor customer service (only $30 credit on $165 shoe, no replacement), Durability concerns offset eco-friendly positioning.
GREATS Shoe — 8/10
Solid choice. Worth buying if it solves your problem.
What we liked: Machine-washable—easy maintenance without specialized products, Beautiful, distinctive design with subtle branding, Eco-friendly vegan materials and recycled plastic construction, Comfortable fit, true to size, Durable high-grade construction with quality craftsmanship.
Worth knowing: Slightly heavier than some lighter competitors like SUAVS, Made in China rather than Italy.
Common questions
Is the Rothy’s Mary Jane or the GREATS Shoe better?
We rated both 8/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Rothy’s Mary Jane: My favorite Rothy's yet—elegant, comfy, and eco-conscious, but the tight bow can strain straps. GREATS Shoe: Solid choice. Worth buying if it solves your problem.
How much do the Rothy’s Mary Jane and GREATS Shoe cost?
The GREATS Shoe is listed at $119. We don't have a current price on file for the Rothy’s Mary Jane — check the latest on its review page.
What's the difference between the Rothy’s Mary Jane and the GREATS Shoe?
Short version — Rothy’s Mary Jane: My favorite Rothy's yet—elegant, comfy, and eco-conscious, but the tight bow can strain straps. GREATS Shoe: Solid choice. Worth buying if it solves your problem.