Our verdict
The Rothy’s Mary Jane and Hey Dude Shoes are close. We gave the Rothy’s Mary Jane a slight edge at 6/10 over the Hey Dude Shoes at 5.5/10 — close enough that fit matters more than the score. Gorgeous style undermined by bow-strap durability issues and disappointing customer service—wouldn't buy again.
Our pick
Rothy’s Mary Jane
Hey Dude Shoes
Side by side
| Attribute | Rothy’s Mary Jane | Hey Dude Shoes |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 6/10 | 5.5/10 |
| Best for | Gorgeous style undermined by bow-strap durability issues and disappointing customer service—wouldn't buy again. | They nail comfort and convenience, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality concerns make them hard to recommend. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Rothy’s Mary Jane if…
Gorgeous style undermined by bow-strap durability issues and disappointing customer service—wouldn't buy again.
- Stylish bow design with elegant aesthetic
- Comfortable fit with rounded toe
Choose the Hey Dude Shoes if…
They nail comfort and convenience, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality concerns make them hard to recommend.
- Lightweight (only 177g)
- Very comfortable and cushioned
Why we rate them this way
Rothy’s Mary Jane — 6/10
Gorgeous style undermined by bow-strap durability issues and disappointing customer service—wouldn't buy again.
What we liked: Stylish bow design with elegant aesthetic, Comfortable fit with rounded toe, Made from recycled plastic (sustainable), Vegan leather soles that elevate the look, Good price for quality.
Worth knowing: Bow straps tear easily after just a few wears due to design flaw, Requires very tight bow that strains the fabric, No repair or replacement offered, only $30 discount, Disappointing customer service response to durability issue.
Hey Dude Shoes — 5.5/10
They nail comfort and convenience, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality concerns make them hard to recommend.
What we liked: Lightweight (only 177g), Very comfortable and cushioned, Machine-washable, Breathable cotton lining, Ideal for travel and casual errands.
Worth knowing: Aggressively casual style (not for style-conscious people), Quality defects and product issues, Cushioning packs down with heavy use, Unsatisfactory customer service.
Common questions
Is the Rothy’s Mary Jane or the Hey Dude Shoes better?
We rated the Rothy’s Mary Jane 6/10 and the Hey Dude Shoes 5.5/10, so we lean Rothy’s Mary Jane — but it depends on what you want it for (see "which one is right for you" on the page).
What's the difference between the Rothy’s Mary Jane and the Hey Dude Shoes?
Short version — Rothy’s Mary Jane: Gorgeous style undermined by bow-strap durability issues and disappointing customer service—wouldn't buy again. Hey Dude Shoes: They nail comfort and convenience, but the aggressively casual aesthetic and quality concerns make them hard to recommend.