Our verdict
The Vessi Shoes and the Rothy’s are too close to call — we rated both 8.5/10. There's no clear winner here, so it comes down to what you want it for. We break that down below.
Vessi Shoes
Rothy’s
Side by side
| Attribute | Vessi Shoes | Rothy’s |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.5/10 | 8.5/10 |
| Best for | Vessi's waterproofing works—paper towel stayed dry—and at $140 you get breathable, washable sneakers, though the style's polarizing. | At $145–$165, the recycled-bottle construction and machine-washability genuinely deliver; just size up half a step. |
| Standouts |
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
Which one is right for you?
Choose the Vessi Shoes if…
Vessi's waterproofing works—paper towel stayed dry—and at $140 you get breathable, washable sneakers, though the style's polarizing.
- Waterproofing actually works (water beads off, paper towel test proved it)
- Lightweight, comfortable, and breathable
Choose the Rothy’s if…
At $145–$165, the recycled-bottle construction and machine-washability genuinely deliver; just size up half a step.
- Machine-washable
- Made from recycled plastic bottles
Why we rate them this way
Vessi Shoes — 8.5/10
Vessi's waterproofing works—paper towel stayed dry—and at $140 you get breathable, washable sneakers, though the style's polarizing.
What we liked: Waterproofing actually works (water beads off, paper towel test proved it), Lightweight, comfortable, and breathable, Machine-washable and easy to clean, Slip-resistant sole for wet conditions, No sweaty feet like traditional rain boots.
Worth knowing: Polarizing style—not for everyone aesthetically, Won't protect against puddles deeper than the shoe top.
Rothy’s — 8.5/10
At $145–$165, the recycled-bottle construction and machine-washability genuinely deliver; just size up half a step.
What we liked: Machine-washable, Made from recycled plastic bottles, Comfortable and versatile for casual to dressy occasions, Durable—reviewer still wearing after 4+ years, Responsive to customer feedback.
Worth knowing: Runs snug—requires sizing up half a step, High price point ($145–$165), Poor warranty service (offered $30 credit instead of fixing design flaw).
Common questions
Is the Vessi Shoes or the Rothy’s better?
We rated both 8.5/10 — it's a genuine toss-up. Vessi Shoes: Vessi's waterproofing works—paper towel stayed dry—and at $140 you get breathable, washable sneakers, though the style's polarizing. Rothy’s: At $145–$165, the recycled-bottle construction and machine-washability genuinely deliver; just size up half a step.
What's the difference between the Vessi Shoes and the Rothy’s?
Short version — Vessi Shoes: Vessi's waterproofing works—paper towel stayed dry—and at $140 you get breathable, washable sneakers, though the style's polarizing. Rothy’s: At $145–$165, the recycled-bottle construction and machine-washability genuinely deliver; just size up half a step.