Everlane Review: The 15 Best Everlane Products That Will Revolutionize Your Closet

We Tried It
Follow us
The Top 15 Everlane Products
Everlane Review: The top 15 women’s styles

You have probably seen or heard of Everlane by now.  They are one of the companies that is really leading the movement towards ethically and sustainably made fashion. Read on for our full Everlane Review and discover the 15 items your closet can’t live without.

Everlane’s mission, which we believe is important to our Everlane Review is this: “We believe we can all make a difference. Our way: Exceptional quality. Ethical Factories. Radical Transparency.”

I love their mission and I also love their clothing! Their clothes are gorgeous and make up a big percentage of my closet. Find out why in our Everlane Review and discover my top 15 Everlane picks! What are the best Everlane clothes you need in your closet?

Everlane Review: What we love about Everlane 👍🏻

  • They are focused on high-quality classic pieces that will be in your closet forever.
  • As you will see in our Everlane Review, they price their items lower than most other higher-end retailers.
  • They have amazing customer service. 
  • My Everlane items are my favorite items in my closet!

What we don’t love about Everlane 🤷🏼‍♀️

  • Since Everlane is mostly an online retailer, sizes can be hard before you start to get to know the brand.  Below I have indicated whether things run true to size or you should size up or down. 
  • I haven’t found any pants I have loved yet, but I really like my pants stretchy and traditionally theirs have been less stretchy.  I did see recently they have some stretchy styles, so I’m excited to try those out!

Without further ado, let’s jump right into our top 15 Best Everlane Products for women.

Everlane Best Product #15: The Cotton Crew

Size: XS – True to Size

Everlane Cotton Crew

The Everlane Cotton Crew is a classic! This style is why Jennifer Aniston always looks so amazing, a perfect short-sleeve tee (ok, among other things!). But, this tee does not disappoint and the fitted style is very flattering.

How to style: Style this with a pair of high waisted denim and some loafers. 

Everlane Top Item #14: The Lightweight French Terry Shrunken Hoodie

Size: XS – True to Size

Everlane Review: Lightweight French Terry Shrunken Hoodie

I was so surprised by how soft The Lightweight French Terry Shrunk Hoodie is! It is nice and light with a soft yet structured shape. I really liked that this is a cropped fit too because sometimes hoodies can kind of swallow you up!

How to style: Style this with s pair of leggings, white sneakers and a leather jacket for a warm laid back look.

Everlane Top Item #13: The Air Oversized Crew Tee $25

Size: XXS – Size Down one size

Everlane Review: The Air Oversized Crew

This tee was an add on for me because you get free shipping if you buy two items! After I received it, I was thrilled that I had ordered it. This tee is very lightweight while not being see-through. It is super comfy, yet keeps its shape throughout the day. I love the oversized look when you are dressing a little more casual. I have this in white.

How to Style: Style this with a plaid flannel top, a pair of leggings and some Rothy’s (read our full Rothy’s Review and get our Rothy’s Promo Code) sneakers.  

Everlane Top Item #12: The Cotton Mockneck Crop $50

Size: S – Size Up One Size

Everlane: Cotton Mockneck

The Everlane Cotton Mockneck Crop sweater is made from the same silhouette as their cashmere crop sweater, but the cotton fabric makes it a little bit more wearable and breathable. It is super comfy and bonus: it can be thrown in the washing machine, unlike its cashmere sister! I have this sweater in bone.

How to Style: Style this with a pair of black jeans and camel Rothy’s Merino Collection points. 

Everlane Top Item #11: The Pima Stretch Long-Sleeve $32

Size: XS – True to Size

Pima Stretch Long-Sleve Everlane

Ever get a new piece of clothing in the mail, feel it and then wonder why all of your clothes don’t feel as soft? Apparently Pima cotton is magic! This is the world’s softest long-sleeve tee shirt! It has a more fitted appearance but is still incredibly flattering. I have this Everlane style in white.

How to style:  Throw this on with a scarf, skinny jeans and some cute M. Gemi loafers!

Everlane Top Item #10: The Air Dolman Tee $18

Size: XS – True to Size

Everlane Dolman Tee

This is the perfect Everlane wardrobe staple! The Everlane Air Tee is made of very luxurious cotton and is not see-through. It drapes very nicely and does not accentuate any bumps or bulges! I have this short-sleeve tee in black and white.

How to Style: Style this tee with a great pair of denim and some OTK boots for a very chic look!

Everlane Top Item #9: The Square Mockneck Tee $25

Size: XS – True to Size

Everlane Square Mockneck

This Everlane cute mock turtleneck has a very classic look. It has a boxy silhouette that makes it very figure flattering even in the lighter colors. I have this top in white.

How to style: Style this with a black leather jacket and a pair of lighter wash straight denim with Chelsea style boots. 

Everlane Top Item #8: The ReCotton Henley $28

Size: S – Size up one size

The ReCotton Henley

Henley’s are everywhere this year and this Everlane ReCotton Henly does not disappoint! This is made of 60% recycled cotton and is super soft. My favorite feature is the oversized white buttons that really pop on the darker colors. I have this top in the washed black color.

How to style: Style this top with a cute pair of vintage overalls and a pair of white tennis shoes. 

Everlane Top Item #7: The Air Long-Sleeve Tee $28

Size: XS – True to size

Everlane Air Long-Sleeve Tee

A total staple in any wardrobe! This is a great long-sleeve tee that is very breathable, but at the same time not see-through. My favorite thing about this tee is that it does not show any of your lumps or bumps the way stretchier, lower quality shirts do. This shirt looks polished and can be worn by itself or under a jacket for added layers! I have the black and white color options in this style.

How to style: Style this with skinny jeans and Rothy’s for a cute casual look. 

Everlane Top Item #6: The Everlane Cotton V-Neck $18

Size: XS – True to size

Everlane Cotton V-Neck

I have the Everlane Cotton V-Neck in grey, black and white. It is such a great staple! The v-neck is very figure flattering and the material is thick enough to not be see-through. These great v-necks can be worn by themselves or under sweaters for winter layering. And let’s talk about that price – $18!! How can you go wrong?

How to style: Style the white cotton v-neck with a pair of distressed denim and some brown loafers.

Everlane Top Item #5: The Oversized Alpaca Crew $95

Size: S – Sized up for an oversized fit

Everlane Alpaca Crew

I have to be honest and say I have never had anything made from Alpaca before so I had no idea what to expect when I ordered the Oversized Alpaca Crew! Thankfully Everlane has amazing customer service and a great return policy so I took my chances. It looked warm and fluffy online – the kind of warm and fluffy that makes up all my winter sitting by the fire dreams come true. And when I received it – it was even warmer and fluffy in person! It is not super itchy, but sometimes I do wear an undershirt for added comfort. I loved this style so much I purchased it in Almond and Heather Charcoal!

How to style: Style this with a pair of Spanx leather leggings and some black velvet Birdies (read our Birdies Review).

Everlane Top Item #4: The Cotton Long Sleeve Crew $25

Size: XS – True to Size

Cotton Everlane Long Sleeve Crew

I feel like I am always on the lookout for great long sleeve t-shirts and the Everlane Cotton Long Sleeve Crew is GREAT! It is fitted enough to not look sloppy, but loose enough to not show bumps or lumps. This tee is made of very high-quality cotton and will be one you are constantly reaching for in your closet.

How to style: Style this with a pair of cut off dark skinny jeans and modern brown loafers for a classic look. 

Everlane Top Item #3 The Cashmere Turtleneck Dress $165

Size: XXS – Sized Down for a more fitted look

Everlane Cashmere Turtleneck Dress

This dress is a CLASSIC! What do you get when you put Everlane’s cashmere, a turtleneck and a mini dress silhouette together? The answer is PERFECTION! This would be a great dress for any holiday event you have. It is warm and cozy but still looks formal and classy. I have this in the black option.

How to style: Style this with a pair of OTK boots, classic pearl earrings and a red lip for the ultimate holiday outfit. 

Everlane Top Item #2: The Modern Loafer $168 (size 8, half size up)

Size: 8 – Half size-up

Everlane Modern Loafer

I have a pair of black limited edition Everlane Modern Loafers that has a tassel, but no matter what version of this lovely shoe you buy, you can’t go wrong! You will find lots of support and structure in this shoe and quality that I literally think will last over a decade. These loafers are absolutely gorgeous!

How to style: Style these with a pair of skinny jeans, black turtleneck and brown leather racket for a chic classic look. Be sure to see the Everlane Loafers in our Loafer Roundup.

And, drum roll please….

The #1 Top Everlane Review Item – The Cashmere Crew $100

Size: XS – True to size

The best Everlane product for women: The Cashmere Crew

Everlane’s Cashmere Crew is probably one of their most iconic pieces. For only $100 you can get an exceptionally crafted cashmere sweater that is sure to grace your closet for years to come! Their cashmere is very soft, yet strong enough to wear on a regular basis. I have this sweater in Red, Grey Frost, Dengal and Camel.

How to style:  Style this with your favorite pair of black skinny jeans and pointed flats for an instantly polished look! Throw on a chic headband to channel your inner Blair Waldorf! 

Everlane Review: The Final Verdict.

Ok, ok, I love everything from Everlane. I have had great success with the items I have ordered! 

These 15 items can all be worn in a variety of ways – whether dressed up or dressed down. You could create an Everlane capsule wardrobe with their classic pieces!

And the cherry on the top is that Everlane is a great company with excellent service. Be sure to check out Everlane.

4 thoughts on “Everlane Review: The 15 Best Everlane Products That Will Revolutionize Your Closet”

Leave a Reply