Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 1

Online Grocery Delivery – We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist

Just so you know, We Tried It may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Don't worry, we will only recommend the products we actual like (and we've reviewed) - and even better, there's no cost to you.

shipt vs. walmart+ - best grocery delivery

Online Grocery Delivery Services Review: You have probably seen the advertisements for the new Target Delivery Service, Shipt. Or more recently, the new Walmart Delivery service, WalMart+. Or seen Kroger (or King Soopers) advertise Clicklist (actually, now just called “Pickup”). Which online grocery delivery service is the best? Which online grocery is the cheapest?

We tried them all, so you don’t have to. If you want the ;tldr (too long, didn’t read), we really like Shipt. If you’re ready to try Shipt, be sure to use our Shipt Promo Code and read our full Shipt Review.

Or read on to learn how to decided that Shipt was the best online grocery service. We compare prices, service and speed!

Who’s cheaper: Shipt, Walmart+, Instacart or Clicklist?

Many people don’t know this, but MOST online ordering sites mark up the cost for the food. Want to get something through Door Dash or Uber Eats? They are probably marking up the cost by about 10% or so. Not a lot, barely enough to notice, however, it adds up really quick.

We were actually tipped off by this while visiting Instacart’s website. One part of Instacart’s website has us a little alarmed. Were we overpaying for products?

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 2
Instacart, more expensive than in-store?

So, we decided to do a test between Shipt, Clicklist and Instacart. We took a recent order of about 14 items (watch the comparison video to see the whole list) ranging from eggs to laundry detergent.

Meet the Contenders: Shipt, Walmart, Instacart + Clicklist

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 3

Don’t miss our full Shipt Review. Now owned by Target, this delivery service now allows you to order from Safeway, Target, Bed Bath & Beyond, GNC and more.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 4

Walmart recently came out swinging, with their answer to Amazon Prime meets Shipt. How does it stand up?

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 5

The “old dog” in the grocery delivery service. This service provides delivery from many stores (such as Target, Whole Foods, Costco and Kroger stores).

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 6

Now called Kroger Pickup (or King Soopers Pickup, depending upon location), Clicklist is the service that allows you to pull your car up to the grocery store at a designated time and get your groceries loaded into your car.

Who isn’t listed here? Shipt vs. Amazon Grocery and more

Amazon Grocery stands as one of the most obvious missing online grocery stores in this review. Amazon’s decision to use Whole Foods to deliver groceries is a very wise move, and the selection reflects that; however, it does limit their options on what they offer for customers. But if you’re a Whole Food shopper, Amazon’s got your back. The selection is VERY limited for now, but at least it’s something!

It is simply too difficult to comparison shop Shipt vs. Amazon Grocery vs. Walmart+ with how different the seleciton is.

Shipt vs. Clicklist vs. Instacart – Who is Cheaper?

In our first comparison we did – Shipt was SLIGHTLY Cheaper. However, we recently compared Shipt with Walmart+ for a recent order we completed with Shipt and we were actually surprised at the results.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 3

$189.87

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 4

$179.87

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 5

$201.21

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 6

$198.76

As you can see here, Shipt’s groceries were cheaper by a small margin when you simply look at the price of the groceries. However, the reason why both Shipt and Walmart are green is that Walmart did not have some of the premium brands we typically buy at Target/Shipt: like many of the Tillamook Cheese products. In that case, we substituted some less-premium brands – and that drove down the price.

Clicklist/Kroger usually has the same offers as it offers in-store. For example, you can usually find the 3 Coke 12 Packs for $10 at King Soopers and using Clicklist. Coke products on Shipt are almost always full retail price. If you spent the time looking for the best deal, Clicklist might be much cheaper.

Shipt Vs. Clicklist Vs. Instacart – Fees

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 3

$99/year

Shipt’s pricing is pretty straight forward. It is $99 a year for unlimited deliveries of orders over $35. It’s $7 for orders under $35.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 4

$98/year

Walmart+ also offers a convenient way to pay only $12.95/month if you’d rather not pay for the full year at a time. Groceries are delivered free over $35 and free shipping on all online orders.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 5

$3.99/order or $99/year

$3.99 for same-day orders over $35. Fees vary for one-hour deliveries, club store deliveries, and deliveries under $35. Or all-you-can-order for $99/year.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 6

$4.95/order

The first 3 orders are free. After that, ClickList is $4.95/order.

The winner, again, here is Shipt. Here’s how the order totals look when you add in the fees, assuming you do 30 orders a year.

Who’s faster? Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 3

About 2 hours

With Shipt, we consistently see about 2 hour waits for delivery.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 4

2 Hours + $10 or 4-6 Hours Free

This was an interesting wrinkle. You can get all grocery orders delivered about 4 – 6 hours later for free, but you have to pay $10 for an order if you want it in 2 hours.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 5

About 2 Hours

Typically about 2 hours, however, we saw some days that the wait was longer.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 6

About 12 Hours

During the middle of the day, waits are much lower. However, if you want and order after 4 PM, you will probably wait until the next day.

Grocery Delivery Service, who’s more friendly?

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 3

Super friendly

We don’t know what Shipt does for their training, but we’ve had the nicest shoppers!

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 4

Eh…

It actually looks like Walmart uses Door Dash for delivery, at least in our city. It wasn’t really clear how substitutions worked, etc.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 5

Good

Not as nice as the Shipt folks, but still good people.

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 6

Good

Nothing wrong with a King Sooper or Kroger Employee – but nothing amazing, either.

Shipt vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist: The winner + final verdict

Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 3

Winner

  • Quickest delivery
  • Comes to you
  • Cheaper after 20 order than Clicklist
  • Cheapest overall
Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 4

Good for the right person

  • Cheapest overall price
  • Great if you are already a Walmart Shopper
  • Not great if you don’t typically shop at Walmart
Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 5

Good

  • Good alternative to Shipt
  • Best if you like to shop from many different stores
Online Grocery Delivery - We compare Shipt vs. Walmart+ vs. Instacart vs. Clicklist 6

Good

Other Perks

One of the extra perks of Walmart’s grocery delivery service is that members receive two big bonuses not found on other online delivery services:

  1. $0.05 Off Fuel – not huge (only save $0.50 or so a fill-up), but something
  2. Free shipping on Walmart.com with no minimum order. Obviously, this is a shot over Amazon’s bow, but an interesting one to say the least.

Best Online Grocery Delivery Service – Final Thoughts

Saying what the best online grocery delivery service is kinda like saying what the best grocery store is – it really depends. We, frankly, use both Shipt and Amazon Grocery (via Whole Foods). But that’s also where we would shop in person.

We also shop, in-person at Costco a lot (available via Instacart). We don’t use Instacart for Costco, however, because they mark up prices on Costco’s site AND Costco frequently changes their stock.

So, for us, if we had to pick one winner, it’d be Shipt! But if you are a tried-and-true WalMart Shopper, check out Walmart+. You’ll soon be spoiled by not having to go to the grocery store every again.

Leave a Comment