Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review

Allbirds Review: Is the sustinable shoe company worth the price? Dive into our honest Allbirds review to learn more about this awesome new brand that is taking over people's feet. 

Updated October 2019: For our Allbirds Review, we added all the great new styles that Allbirds has added - including the new Allbirds Flats, Mizzles and much, much more.

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review IMG_1504 Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review we-tried-it-we-loved-it2
  • ;tldr Allbirds review

    The most comfortable shoes we own. Can be washed and worn without socks.

  • His Allbirds Review

    I wear these shoes all the time. They pair well with jeans and love that you can wash them.

  • Her Allbirds Review

    I call these “kittens” because they are like wearing kittens on your feet.

What are Allbirds?

Allbirds is a unique shoe brand. They are made from wool, which makes them insanely comfortable (like whoa!) and washable (double whoa!). You can also wear them without socks because the wool acts like socks (without the stink). They only have two styles - Wool Runners and Wool Loungers.

Allbirds says, "It turns out the most, the comfortable shoes are made of wool." We agree.

Allbirds Review - What makes Allbirds, Allbirds?

When we origionally did our first Allbirds Review - they only had two basic styles: Wool Runners and Wool Loungers (+ Smallbirds for the kiddos - get it?). Allbirds now come in several different styles. We'll dive into that in a moment!

Funny story. Much like Mizzen + Main, we didn't love Allbirds at first try. We came across them because they were taking Silicon Valley by storm. Mr. We Tried It got the all black pair and, frankly, they looked like orthopedic shoes. The black fabric on black soles looked chunky. It looked really bad.

Thankfully, Allbirds has incredible customer service (more on that in a second) and free returns. They took the shoes back and got a refund.

Several months went by and we felt compelled to try Allbirds again, but a different color. He got the grey Allbirds with the white soles. They looked much better and were hooked.

He wore them every day. Literally, every day.

Then, Mrs. We Tried It saw Allbirds in a STYLE Magazine and decided she wanted a pair. She got the Lounger style and has wore them almost every day since.

Usually she just wears them around the house, but she loves them so much that occasionally, she just can't take them off, even if they look like slippers. As she says, "It's worth it." That's incredible coming from a woman with Purple Sparkle Shoes.

The shoes are incredibly comfortable. They have good support and are very light. They keep your feet warm in the winter and cool during the summer. We wouldn't recommend them if it's rainy or snowy (wearing them wet is no bueno).

So, let's look at the actual shoes.

Here is the original style, the Wool Runners:

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review Allbirds_M_Wool_Runner_Kotare_GREY_ANGLE-1024x1024

Allbirds Wool Runners: The OG.

The wool runners are your everyday shoes. They are "Runners" but since we don't ever "Run" (unless it's to an ice cream truck), we can't tell you how good of a running shoe they are. They are, however, incredibly comfortable.

The whole upper is made with wool. The sole is a very comfortable rubber. There is also a wool-lined rubber insole that is super comfortable, too.

Shortly after Allbirds released the Wool Runners, Allbirds decided to come out with the follow-up, the Wool Lounger:

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review Allbirds_M_Wool_Lounger_BLACK_ANGLE-1024x1024

Allbirds Wool Lounger: The most comfortable Allbirds!

The Allbirds Wool Loungers are like slippers. They are much more casual. The black ones are what we have and they really do look like Slippers. Mr. won't wear them out of the house, but Mrs. will.

They are very similar to the Wool Runners, but with no laces. They have the same sort of Wool Upper, Rubber Sole and Wool-lined insole.

Then, after Allbirds heard the We Tried It crew had a kiddo, they came out with a kids version of the Wool Lounger. These are perfect because our little boy hates socks.

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review Smallbirds_Wool_Runner_GREY_ANGLE-1024x1024

Smallbirds: The best shoes for kids that hate socks!

What's the difference between Allbirds?

Wool vs. Tree: What's the difference? Which Allbirds should I buy?

Allbirds Wool Shoes:

Allbird Wool Runners.
The OG. The origional. The one and only. 

The Allbirds Wool Runner are the origional for a reason: With fibers that are 20% the diameter of human hair, our superfine merino wool is breathable, temperature-regulating, and moisture-wicking, all without that irritating scratchiness. They even inspired this Amazon Allbirds Knockoff.

The Good: These shoes are awesome to wear without socks. They are durable and warm but breathable.

The Bad: A little warm for the dead of summer. Don't hold their shape as good as Tree-based shoes. 

Allbirds Wool Lounger
More lounge, less runner. 

Made from the same material as the Wool Runners, these shoes are great for lounging around the house. They look more like slippers than shoes. 

The Good: The perfect shoe to wear around the house or run to the store. 

The Bad: Look more like slippers than shoes. Don't hold their shape as good as Tree-based shoes. 

Allbirds Runner-up Mizzles
The funny looking shoes with a serious purpose.

Think of these as Allbirds Boots - they are made of wool but have Puddle Guard™. It's a breathable bio-based shield living beneath a reinforced wool upper treated with a fluorine-free coating.

The Good: Comfortable shoes to wear in the rain and snow. 

The Bad: Not the best looking shoes. 

Allbirds TREE Shoes:

It's a bit easier to understand shoes made of Wool, but what about a Tree? What does Allbirds say about their Tree shoes? 

"Thanks to their fiber and a clean closed-loop process, we have a naturally-derived, renewable material that’s much easier on the environment than traditional fabrics. Did we mention it’s also comfortable, breathable, and silky-smooth?"

These shoes feel more like a more sturdy, more breathable cotton. But don't worry - the soles and inside still have tons of Wool!

Allbirds Tree Runners
The style of Wool Runners, but made with Trees!

If you had to pick one style of Allbirds, this might be it. They are super comfortable and hold their structure a lot better than the Wool Runners. They provide 90% of the comfort but hold their structure a lot better.

The Good: Hold their shape and structure very well. Perfect for summer.  

The Bad: Not as comfortable as the origional Wool Runners. 

Allbirds Tree Loungers
The style of Wool Loungers, but made with Trees!

Similar to the Tree Runners - these hold their shape very well over the course of time and are still super comfortable. 

The Good: Also hold their shape and structure very well. Perfect for summer and running errands.

The Bad: Not as comfortable as the origional Wool Loungers. 

Allbirds Breezers - Tree Flat
Super-low profile flats.

To be 100% honest, we haven't reviewed these yet. However, they look interesting. They don't have a lot of structure and almost look like low-profile stock. We prefer the look of Rothy's (read our full Rothy's Review

The Good: Low profile, breathable. 

The Bad: Looks a little small and awkward. 

Allbirds Tree Skippers
The prefect summer shoe. 

Mr. We Tried It probaly wears this style the most. They are super light and super breezy. He likes to wear his shoes loose and these are perfect for that. He wore these all over Disneyland and they look like new!

The Good: Super casual, goes well with shorts in the summer. Comfortable, light and breezy. 

The Bad: Don't provide the same support as some of the other shoes. 

What else does allbirds make?

Smallbirds
As we mentioned, Allbirds make the Smallbirds shoe. What's the quick review on Smallbirds? Our kids loves them, too. We don't love the the laces (he's squirmy), but we love they can be washed. Even better, the Smallbirds can be worn without socks, too. Our kiddo hates socks. Go figure... Real our full Smallbirds Review.

Allbirds Socks

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review allbirds-socks-review2-233x300 It shouldn't come as a surprise that Allbirds has also got into the sock game. The soft and breezy Trino™ Quarters are supposedly the perfect comfort companion for your Allbirds shoes. Which we don't really agree with - since we never wear socks with our Allbirds. 



Allbirds Sleep Mask

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review allbirds-sleep-mask-300x176 For some off reason, Allbirds also make a sleep mask. Who knows...

How Much are Allbirds?

Allbirds Runners and Loungers for men and women are all $95. The Allbirds Breezers Flats are also $95. The Mizzles are $135. Kids (SMallbirds) are $55.

Here's where we've seen the best deal on Allbirds online

Are allbirds worth it?

While 95 bucks for shoes may be on the high side, these shoes are absolutely worth it. Two key reasons we give Allbirds a positive review:

  1. They can be washed. See below on more information about how they stand up to washing, but it REALLY helps. 
  2. Wearing without socks is really game changing. It sounds odd, but we both love to wear Allbirds without socks. The feeling of wool on your naked feet is a thing a beauity. 

Can you really wash allbirds?

In short: yes. And they wash really well. Here are quick instructions on How to Wash Allbirds.

Mr. We Tried It has had a pair of the grey Allbirds since March of this year. He wore them about every other day, if not more often. They've been washed probably 4 times and they have held up really well. 

Here are his Allbirds hundreds of wears later (and several washes later)

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review IMG_1459-1024x768

My allbirds literally hundreds of wears later.

They still look really good. They've lost some of their structure, as you'll see in the next photo (old pair of Allbirds on the left, new pair of Allbirds on the right), the structure difference isn't as obvious when you are wearing the shoes. I'd say they are only slightly less comfortable many months later - the biggest difference is the "fuzz" of the wool doesn't last for 6+ months. 

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review IMG_1469-1024x768

Do the allbirds hold up over time?

While the photos don't look like it - they shoes actually hold up really well. They look much better on your feet. See this illustration of me wearing my Allbirds:

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review qCg4TNr-Imgur-1

 

What don't we love about Allbirds?

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review Allbirds_M_Wool_Runner_Kotare_BLACK_PROFILEL-e1514086743183-300x146 As we mentioned, we didn't like the look of the first pair of Allbirds we purchase, the all black pair. They looked a bit like Orthopedic shoes. You can be the judge of how ugly they are. Allbirds customer service is incredible. We simply requested to return them and their customer service took care of the rest. If you have any issues at all, their customer service will be there to help. 

We also uncovered a bit of an odd issue with Allbirds. We don't know if it's just because he has huge "big" toes or what - but some of the fabric where the big toe is, on the inside of the shoes, is broken. This sounds like a really big deal, but only if you stick your finger in the area can you really tell there is anything wrong. 

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review allbirds-review-inside

We contacted customer service about the issue and they said they are working on it. We believe them. They gave us a solution (getting some moleskin repair to put on the inside) and a discount on my next pair. We're optimistic that they will continue to improve the product - but you don't even notice that little issue. 

Allbird's website also says that Allbirds don't stink. That's partially true. They smell far less than a traditional shoe, but if you haven't washed them in a while, they WILL smell - especially in the summer heat. Not a big deal, but these aren't miracle shoes. 


Do you wear socks with Allbirds?

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review socks-with-allbirds-1024x576

This is a tough question: just because it comes down to preference. We do not wear socks with our Allbirds, ever. We might wear them with the Mizzles, but it hasn't been super cold yet - so we haven't had the chance to test them in the conditions. 

It's interesting that Allbirds now does sell socks, but we can't recommend wearing socks with Allbirds, unless they are the Mizzles.  


Allbirds Review: We test the claims 

  • You can Wear Allbirds without socks

    Yes. You can wear Allbirds without socks. In fact, we never wear them with socks.

  • We agree. Allbirds is the most comfortable shoe we own.

  • Allbirds don't stink

    Allbirds don’t smell as bad as other shoes that you would wear without socks. However, if you wear them for multiple days without washes, they can start to stink a LITTLE. They aren’t magic.

  • You can wash ALlbirds easily

    We’ve both washed our Allbirds multiple times, without an issue. They clean easily!


Where do you buy Allbirds

Allbirds Review: Our 9+ Pair Honest Allbirds Shoe Review where-to-buy-allbirds-1024x385

The best place to buy Allbirds is on their website. They have several stores (we've visited the one in New York City) where you can try the products on your own. 

Allbirds were available at Nordstrom for a short period of time, but appear to be sold out now. 

If you are on the fence about any of their products, we'd encourage you to get them for one simple reason: their return policy is amazing!

Allbirds Return Policy

Here's what their return policy says:

30 days, no questions asked. Not bad, huh? If you’re not walking on clouds by day 30, you can return/exchange your shoes for free, even if you've worn them out in the wild!

It sounds too good to be true, doesn't it? Well, it's this true - and better. We've had shoes that were even outside of the window that we were able to exchange. I wouldn't push it, but Allbirds has an amazing return policy with great customer service. You can even call and talk to a real, live person if you want to. Pretty cool, eh?


Allbirds Review: The Verdict

If you had to buy one shoe to wear the rest of your life, we'd recommend a pair of Allbirds. Sure, they aren't going to surpass Allen Edmonds or Christian Louboutin in the dressy category, but they are incredibly comfortable and don't look like Crocs.

They are a respectable shoe you can wear with a lot of different outfits, wear without socks (how liberating!) and even wash when they get a little stinky.

Buy a pair of Allbirds today.

Here's where we've found the best deal on Allbirds.

 

PS: Have you seen the Amazon Allbirds Knockoffs? Read our honest Amazon Allbird Knockoffs review.